Roadcarvin

Main menu

  • Home
  • Articles
    • Magazine Sections
      • The Front Page
      • Blogs
      • Events
      • News and reviews
      • Photography Equipment
      • Photos - All-time popular
      • Photos - Latest additions
      • Photos - Recent popular
      • Recent popular pages
      • What's New
    • All-Time Popular Content
    • Recent Additions
    • Recent Popular Content
  • Motorcycle Equipment
    • Motorcycle Equipment Reviews and News
  • Photo Gallery
    • Browse the Photo Gallery
    • All-time popular photos
    • Recent additions
    • Recent popular photos
  • Polls
    • Roadcarvin Magazine Polls
  • Roadcarvin
    • Contact Us
    • Site map
    • About Roadcarvin Magazine
      • About us
      • Advertise on Roadcarvin
      • Photo Hot Linking Guide
      • Privacy Policy
      • Terms of Use
Home

Should another company pick up the Buell Motorcycle line?

  • View
  • Results
Author: Michael Curry /// submitted on October 15, 2009 - 5:20pm.
Filed Under
  • Buell
  • Motorcycle News
  • Add new comment

Harley vs Buell

IP
Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on October 17, 2009 - 4:45am.

It's a shame when a large corporation buys your company, and then closes you down a few years later. Too bad HD can't read the handwriting on the wall. A modern, innovative product like Buell was their future. what is HD going to do, when all the gray beards who have kept them going the last decade, are too old to ride or dead and buried. The younger generation has no interest in HD's clunky old product line.

  • reply

YOUR STATEMENT

IP
Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on November 19, 2009 - 6:13am.

the old grey beards never die, harley has been solid 4 over 100 years. u got to be kidding, BUEL? cool. but harleyMC will be strong beyond your lifetime

  • reply

I seem to recall a bailout

IP
Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on December 30, 2009 - 11:25am.

I seem to recall a bailout by the Federal Government already once in my lifetime of Harley Davidson. Slowly they are succombing to an assemply plant only as there parts are made overseas. They are not making any engineering changes and with the sellout of being truly American made even the grey bears will lose interest. Buell was a statement and cutting edge in many areas. They were definetly poised to do something great.

  • reply

Don't sell! keep R&D in

IP
Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on December 2, 2009 - 8:04pm.

Don't sell! keep R&D in house... Economy rebounds in a few years and they come out blasting again...

  • reply

If Buell was Harley's future

IP
Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on April 23, 2010 - 7:18am.

If Buell was Harley's future then, it was a bleak future. I've worked for several Harley shops, and I have to say; I'm not sorry to see Buell go. Buell bikes, are extremly prone to breaking down. The parts were cheap, and they really can't keep up with a zx-14 or other bikes in their class. Erik Buells biggest contribution to Harley was his help building the v-rod which isn't a fast bike, but none the less a good solid bike that rarley has any issues. Marketing Harley's and Buells in the same shop was never going to work. Two demographics in the same shop..."Geezers/hard core cycle purists" vs "young punks, and those who wanted to buy a Harley but didn't want to abandon the young appeal" Harley has supplimented their marketing strategies since with their dark custom line. I'm not sad at all the Buell is gone. The xr1200 is twice the bike the 1125r ever was or would have been. Harley nor it's shop workers will ever miss Buell. Good-bye spirited and free thinkers! We won't get choaked up like Erik. Peace!

  • reply

RE; Buell

IP
Submitted by Anonymous Buelligan (not verified) on April 26, 2010 - 7:36am.

Fine, you don't like Buell, but at least get your facts straight about the XR1200... it's simply not in the same league of performance as the 1125R. The XR1200 is 100 pounds heavier and 50 HP down from the 1125R. But you're right, the XR1200 has shinier pipes. And a ZX-14 will mop the floor with both of us.

The "young punks" (that includes me, I guess) just want a decent v-twin engine in a frame that can actually go around corners without grinding off hard parts. The XB with the old Sporty engine did that for me great, the 1125 even better.

I for one hope Erik Buell bounces back into streetbikes after 2011 when his non-compete clause expires.

  • reply

"The xr1200 is twice the

IP
Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on September 30, 2010 - 11:06am.

"The xr1200 is twice the bike the 1125r ever was or would have been"

Really..that is sort of an apples and oranges comparison. In competition there is no comparison, look at the times posted for the respective races last season.

  • reply

No really

IP
Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on November 8, 2010 - 9:29am.

"The xr1200 is twice the bike the 1125r" is apples to oranges comparison, yes they are both motorcycles but the design, target audience and length of the development cycle are not at all comparable. Its would be much the same as comparing the lap times of the current Harley spec racers to the times posted by a 1125R. they won't be even close. That is not to say the Harley spec racers suck just that they are different bikes. Apples to Oranges.

  • reply

I am not agree with you... I

IP
Submitted by Martin (not verified) on September 5, 2011 - 9:10pm.

I am not agree with you... I am a big HD fan and I have always dream of riding one and of course it would be popular against the next generation. HD is having its own value which wouldn't going to change with changing time. Harley Davidson India

  • reply

HD and Buell

IP
Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on October 21, 2009 - 10:54am.

It will be a sad day once the Buell factory is closed. Buell was finally getting into the modern superbike game. I had just sold my RC51 to get an american made sportbike but now that I hear Buell is going to be no more it makes me sad... I will still buy that 1125R I was looking at though :P

  • reply

I too think it's a shame

IP
Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on October 22, 2009 - 7:44pm.

I too think it's a shame that Buell is shutting down. But, your wrong about interest in HD waning. There is plenty of interest in HD from gray beards and youngsters alike to keep HD afloat. And remeber there will be more gray beards to relace the ones who are dieing off. :)

  • reply

Buell

IP
Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on December 26, 2009 - 11:35am.

In my opinion, Buell never was all that. They didn't have the old skool appeal of Harley-Davidson, and they certainly were no threat to the japanese sport bikes that are out there. So what real purpose do they have? Maybe as a beginner bike for someone who's skill level isn't up to 'Busa level. Other than that, they never really fit in. Sure it was kind of cool to ride a sport bike with a Harley motor. But that's like of like putting a fake ram air hood on a vehicle. It may look cool, but it doesn't work and you're gonna get smoked anyway.

Harleys aren't going anywhere. Sooner or later every one grows up. When they do, they buy a Harley.

  • reply

Comment from a real motorcyclist

IP
Submitted by Fred M. (not verified) on February 15, 2010 - 6:59am.

The Hayabusa isn't a bike for people with riding skill; it's a bike for people who lack riding skill. It's a slow-handling pig of a 570+ pound bike for people who ride in a straight line and twist the throttle. You don't see guys who buy top-notch sport bikes like Ducatis, MV Agustas, Aprilias, and, yes, Buells considering Hayabusas.

The Buell 1125R and 1125CR are among the finest sport bikes made for the street. They are very fast (146HP at the crank, 375lbs. dry), have an incredibly wide powerband, don't have to turn crazy-high RPMs on the highway, have better flickability than 600cc Japanese bikes, and, if you are racing, can be built to put out 175rwhp (185rwhp with an 1190cc kit).

But that's the difference between Buells and Japanese sport bikes: Buell built street bikes that can be run on a track, while the Japanese build track bikes that can be ridden on the street. That's an important difference: The fastest track bike is seldom the fastest street bike (and vice versa). Everything from the Buell's ergonomics to the flat torque curve is optimized for high-performance street riding. Even the engine size and configuration was chosen with no consideration of fitting it into some existing racing class.

Your comment about how "every one grows up" just shows that you haven't. People can be "grown up" an want a bike with sophistication and performance, like a BMW, Honda Gold Wing. Even those who want an American V-Twin might be more interested in the better-engineered Victory line.

My biggest concern in buying my two Buells was whether Harley would still be in business to provide parts for them. I remember the 50% tariff on Japanese bikes over 700ccs that was levied to keep Harley from going bankrupt in the 1980s. Since you're obviously not very in-touch with the motorcycle business, I'll tell you that Harley's problem is an aging demographic. The average age of Harley riders is going up -- disturbingly. It's even to the point where Harley has introduced a trike for some aging would-be riders who can no longer balance or support the weight of a motorcycle. Harley owners are starting later and buying fewer motorcycles throughout their riding lifetimes. Harley has lost the Hells Angels bad ass image and is now seen as a choice for white-collar pretenders and for "returning riders" (old people who have not ridden in decades). Bikes like the 883 Sportsters, which make less power than a Suzuki Burgman 650 scooter, has helped cement the image of Harley as a brand for people who really aren't serious riders.

  • reply

buell

IP
Submitted by valita (not verified) on October 31, 2009 - 5:16am.

I‛ve never liked the looks of the buell but thats just me‚ when I bought my 2010 fat boy lo there were a few people talking about the shut down‚ hd does have to cover the new bike sold that have outstanding warrenty though‚dont know what they would replace them with if a new one was needed though?

  • reply

Buell 1125R

IP
Submitted by Fire (not verified) on November 4, 2009 - 1:04am.

After riding one for more than 140 miles in one day of twisties and highway,
I must have one!!! Sweet bike! And I thought that I didn't like Sport bikes?!
This one is excellent!
H-D is making a BIG mistake in stopping Erik!
I will never be interested in anything else sold under the H-D banner.
Yes, I have also ridden the XR1200R and V-Rod.
They are Boring!

  • reply

Ride This One

IP
Submitted by Antipathy (not verified) on April 3, 2010 - 1:50am.

Yeah right. There are so many things that make up the overall "Harley". I've been riding since 1968, and yes I guess you might call me a "gray beard" and I've never ridden a sport bike, but I know with my race tuned FXDB I could dust most of the 4 cycle rice Grinders. Suzuki 1800, no problem. I'm going today to pick up my new CVO Fat Bob. If all one wants to do is wheel stand and show off, then a sport bike is for them, but don't come off saying us guys have "one foot in the grave" and don't know performance.

  • reply

Buell

IP
Submitted by Anonymous on November 12, 2009 - 1:05pm.

It is a shame. They finally seemed to get it right with the 1125R. Too little too late? If Harley was smart they would integrate a few of the better/more popular Buells into their own product line. In other words put the Harley name/logo on the bike. Just a thought.

  • reply

Do the Right thing, Harley

IP
Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on November 20, 2009 - 6:26am.

I'm a Harley rider, and as a Harley rider, I've been a little annoyed that there have been Buell riders bashing Harley . . .

. . . but I also see their point. I've always seen my bike as more than just a bike. It's a statement, it's a symbol and that symbol isn't: "Take all your lawyers can get for you and screw the little guy."

Harley doesn't represent me with their actions. If I was on the board, I'd sell the rights to Erik Buell for $1.

Let him do something with it if he can.

  • reply

You're one of the good guys.

IP
Submitted by Fred M. (not verified) on February 15, 2010 - 7:11am.

Buell was a division of Harley. We bought well over 100,000 Buell motorcycles at Harley dealerships. Harley shut down Buell and gave us the finger, telling us, in effect, that they aren't interested in having us as customers. So, yeah, we're kind of bitter about that.

Imagine how you would feel about Honda if they bought Harley Davidson and then shut them down some years later, refusing to sell the manufacturing rights to anyone.

But you're right: Harley should sell the manufacturing rights to Erik Buell for $1. Limit him to the Rotax engine and other future engines not derived from, or sourced by, Harley. Maybe even stipulate that he not build any more bikes with air-cooled V-twins -- just to distinguish Buell as not being related to HD any longer.

  • reply

HD is idiots

IP
Submitted by BuellFool (not verified) on November 20, 2009 - 10:15am.

They are complete idiots. HD will fold into oblivion eventually. Buell was the best thing going for HD. Who wants to ride a bike like thier sitting in a lounge chair???... or holding thier arms up in the air like the karate kid??? (answer: Old people and apes)

Even though the new 1125 was crotch rocket...they were designed and built in america and AND was Vtwin... A N D won the AMA championship!!!What more can you (fellow americans) ask for? WE BEAT RICE!

  • reply

Made a big mistake.....

IP
Submitted by Leroysch (not verified) on November 20, 2009 - 7:44pm.

....in not appreciating the fun factor in the 1125R. Picked one up during the recent fire sale....I should have done it sooner!

  • reply

No B.S. there - 1125R rocks

Submitted by Michael Curry on November 20, 2009 - 7:55pm.

I got a chance to ride the Buell 1125R and 1125CR at Infineon and I have to say those bikes kick ass. Here are our 1125R and 1125CR first impressions.

  • reply

BUELL'S are stll alive and will once again thrive just ride one

IP
Submitted by DEPUTYBUELL (not verified) on December 5, 2009 - 9:08am.

It is a true shame when corporate America chooses to trim the fat but they did it before sharpening the knife. This may have not been a big money making venture for Harley at present, but once the economy rebounds they would have won a big chunk of the market.
All it would take is for those potential bike buyers to ride a BUELL and they would see the difference. I am not a close minded Bike enthusiast as I have owned many different Makes,Models,Sizes,Styles... And this Buell XB12X has been one of the most fun bikes of all. Not to mention the amount of torque I am getting with a few performance mods.
I am now looking for the 146hp 1125 street BUELL as my next addition to my motorcycle collection.

"GOD BLESS AMERICA AND MY AMERICAN BUELL"

  • reply

Buell - and MV Agusta

IP
Submitted by Michael (not verified) on January 20, 2010 - 6:47am.

The crisis and economic recession must really have hit Harley hard and taken them by surprise. Especially when you think about them buying MV Agusta (LOVE those bikes by the way!!) and Buell - hope there's a new buyer for both brands - would REALLY hate to see them go into oblivion :-(

  • reply

There were buyers for Buell - and Harley would not sell.

IP
Submitted by Fred M. (not verified) on February 15, 2010 - 7:22am.

Harley refused to sell Buell -- despite there being serious buyers willing to pay a pretty penny for the Buell name, designs, manufacturing rights, and patents.

They claimed that they were doing this for financial reasons. That was a lie. If they were doing it for financial reasons, they would have sold the valuable Buell name and intellectual property (which HD will never incorporate into any Harley). This was a vindictive, spiteful example of corporate political infighting; it was motivated by a few people in Harley who wanted to settle a personal score with Erik Buell. They would rather lay off 180 Americans employed by Buell right before Christmas than let Buell continue to make motorcycles -- for any company.

  • reply

harley vs buell

IP
Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on May 4, 2010 - 12:25pm.

My boys give me guff about having a buell and never riding anything else except buells. I have to say ..from..experience that harley was wrong for closing them down. they should have gave them their own distribution network so they could have their own shops and not hog dealerships. most buell customers feel alienated by the techs when we need parts for our bikes and I ,with all this will buy an 1125r and a firebolt again (crashed one ) low sided on antifreeze in the road surface. I own a thunderbolt s3t and if you know anything about bikes this thing rocks hard. The shame of it is that the parts were slightly inferior which was why Eric made the xblade fuel frame and if you rode a sorted bolt you know what thats like. Harley pissed on Eric by not letting him have the vr1000 motor after some silking out by Eric would have chased every body back to the drawing boards like the firebolt did, forcing mass centralization on the world, but enough sucking this guy off. I give him the props he deserves because as an engineer he has few peers as a racer he had few and as a designer even fewer.

  • reply

BUELL

IP
Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on May 9, 2010 - 1:33pm.

Put a decent motor in the frame like a DUCATI MOTOR.

  • reply

Buell's 1125 is one of the

IP
Submitted by european (not verified) on May 24, 2010 - 10:25am.

Buell's 1125 is one of the best v-tvins out there
with the 1190 kit it will smoke the 1198 R Corse any time
Ducati 1198 R corse 180 hp 134nm on crank
Buell 1190 R 185 hp on rear wheel
Only the ducati desmo v4 can beat that and there are only 1500 made worldwide

Otherwise you have to compare the 1125 to the 1198
1198 134 hp
1125 146 hp

  • reply

what is harley thinking

IP
Submitted by Donny (not verified) on July 14, 2010 - 12:05pm.

Harley davidson cruiser's cost's to much money for today's world.I thought buell's older bikes would have made great sportsters,see my problem is harley riders have turned sportsters into ape hanger cruisers,and there not there sportsters.(PS)there on the right track with the XR1200,but it lack's a rear seat,well a rear seat you can sit on.

  • reply

Harley Davidson and Buell......

IP
Submitted by JohnnyH (not verified) on July 31, 2010 - 6:30am.

From a European perspective, Buell should not have been sold in Harley dealerships, two completely different markets and potential customers. While it is true that it's extremely rare to see a Harley rider under 55, this is as much related to the cost of the bikes as to the image. Other manufacturers like Triumph and BMW have had the same problem in the past and made a deliberate investment in new models designed to appeal to younger riders. This Harley has failed to do and I believe the golden years of strong sales and big profits are now gone. A switch over to some new Ducati Multistrada-type lighter cheaper models with European-style modern looks as part of their range would start to revive interest in the brand from younger 30+ riders. Come on, Harley, lets recreate the Easy Rider days of a cool brand.

  • reply

Buell Motorcycles.

IP
Submitted by jigsaw (not verified) on April 25, 2011 - 11:33pm.

Buell motorcycles was doing very well with the Harley-Davidson company.
In October 2009, Harley-Davidson announced the discontinuation of the Buell product line.
The Motorcycles were very good.
I think someone should take up that company.
Motorcycle accident attorney California

  • reply

Recent Comments

way to go harley you… I am not agree with you... I… Buell Motorcycles.… May be the biggest flop in… I'm just no fan of it, no… New 2011 Vivid Black FXDWG… trade in…

About the author

Michael Curry's picture

Author Name
Michael Curry

Author Bio

Michael has been riding street motorcycles since 1975. He's owned and ridden everything from Hondas to Harleys with a preference for spirited sport-touring riding.

Michael is a Roadcarvin.com co-founder and serves as chief editor, scribe, staff photographer, and other things.

View full user profile

Feeds and Subscriptions

Syndicate content
more

Featured Photo

Three's not a crowd at the 2008 Easyriders Sacramento Show

Guys were doing a double-take... er, a triple-take - these calendar gals were causing traffic problems in the aisles.

Latest Photo

2011 IMS - Harley Girls
Harley-Davison girls at the 2011 IMS show in San Mateo, California.

Subscribe by e-mail

Enter your email address:

Delivered by FeedBurner

Add to Google
Locations of visitors to this page

What's New

Our latest articles

2011 IMS - Harley Girls

2011-2012 International Motorcycle Show Schedule

The Progressive International Motorcycle Shows kicks off the season this weekend in San Mateo, California November 18th - 20th.

Read the rest »
CargoLoc 84060 Motorcycle/ATV Cargo Net 15 inch by 15 inch by 6 hooks

Must-have gear: Bungee cargo net with adjustable ABS plastic hooks

I've used these on my bikes for years. I keep a couple under the seat, in the storage compartment of the rear cowl.

Most cheap ...

Read the rest »
Captain America - 1942 Harley Davidson WLA Liberator

Captain America Rides A 1942 Harley Davidson WLA Liberator

TWO AMERICAN ICONS REUNITE TO SALUTE THE FORCES OF GOOD Harley-Davidson® and Marvel Studio’s Captain America Join Forces to Defend Freedom

On July 22, Marvel Studios releases ...

Read the rest »
More new stuff »

Popular Articles

What other people are reading right now

2008 Harley-Davidson 105th Anniversary V-rod

2008 Harley-Davidson - 105th Anniversary Models

To celebrate the Harley-Davidson 105th Anniversary 14 serialized models featuring an exclusive Anniversary package will be built. Harley-Davidson has been celebrating Anniversaries by building motorcycles with special features as well as throwing big parties for a long time. This Anniversary coincides with the 25th - Silver Anniversary of H.O.G Harley ...

Read the rest »
2009 Buell 1125R - Racing Red - Right Front

2009 Buell 1125CR and 1125R - First Impressions

Track day road test impressions of the 2009 Buell 1125CR and 1125R We rode the 2009 Buell 1125R and 1125CR models at the Buell Inside Pass Track Day at Infineon Raceway. Though our main focus was on the track riding sessions (and the track itself), we learned enough about the ...

Read the rest »
2009 Harley-Davidson Street Glide - Big Sur - Front

2009 Harley-Davidson FLHX Street Glide - First Ride

The 2009 Harley-Davidson Street Glide, part of the 2009 Harley-Davidson Touring lineup is new from the ground up.

This lean and mean bagger features a lowered rear suspension and a smoked mini-wind screen. There are attractive styling features on the Street Glide, and the Black Pearl bike I rode ...

Read the rest »
More popular articles »
Many photos on this site were taken with a Canon EOS 7D, Canon EOS 50D, or other other Canon digital cameras.

Site Map

Use (accessing site content) indicates acceptance of our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use - Roadcarvin Info and Credits

Roadcarvin™ Magazine Contents Copyright © 2005-2013 Michael Curry's Exodus Development, and 3D Software, Inc. All rights reserved. Unauthorized duplication or reproduction prohibited.